The Women’s House of Detention: A Turning Point in Greenwich Village
The Women’s House of Detention, which once stood where we can now enjoy the beautiful Jefferson Market Garden, was more than just a prison. Opened in 1932, the Art Deco-style building was a prominent, though controversial, landmark in the area for nearly four decades. It was the only women’s prison in Manhattan, housing inmates ranging from those awaiting trial to those serving short sentences for offenses often linked to poverty and social marginalization.
Life inside the Women’s House of Detention was harsh. The conditions were overcrowded, and the building’s design —considered to be the world’s only ever art deco prison — was not conducive to humane incarceration and exacerbated the situation. The prison’s notorious reputation grew over the years, fueled by tales of mistreatment, inadequate facilities, and the desperation of its inmates. It was a stark symbol of the failings of the criminal justice system, particularly in its treatment of women, many of whom were there for minor offenses or simply because they had nowhere else to go.
By the late 1960s, the tide began to turn. Activists, community members, and politicians increasingly criticized the facility for its inhumane conditions and called for its closure. The civil rights movement, along with the burgeoning feminist movement, highlighted the injustices faced by the women incarcerated there. These pressures culminated in the decision to close the Women’s House of Detention on June 13, 1971. The inmates were relocated to the newly constructed Rikers Island facility.
The closure of the Women’s House of Detention had a profound impact on Greenwich Village. The immediate effect was the removal of a longstanding eyesore and a source of daily distress for the community. The building’s oppressive presence, often marked by the sound of women shouting from their windows, had cast a shadow over the neighborhood. Its demolition in 1973 was met with mixed feelings—relief for many, nostalgia for some, and for others, a poignant reminder of the need for prison reform.
The closure of the prison played a crucial role in saving the historic Jefferson Market building, which originally housed a courthouse. The Gothic Revival structure, designed by Frederick Clarke Withers and Calvert Vaux, is an architectural gem with a storied past. Following the prison’s closure, there were plans to demolish the entire complex, including the Jefferson Market building.
However, community activists and preservationists saw an opportunity to save the historic structure. They rallied support and campaigned vigorously, emphasizing the building’s architectural and historical significance. Their efforts paid off when the Jefferson Market Courthouse became the Jefferson Market Library, first opening its doors in 1967, even before the prison was officially closed. This helped ensure that the 1874 building would be preserved rather than lost as the Women’s House of Detention was heading for closure and ultimately demolition. The redesign of Jefferson Market’s interior was one of the first adaptive reuse projects in the country and helped solidify the historic preservation movement. This transformation was a testament to the community’s dedication to preserving its heritage and repurposing it for the public good.
Today, the Jefferson Market Library stands as a vibrant cultural and educational hub in Greenwich Village. Its preservation is a direct result of the activism sparked by the closure of the Women’s House of Detention. The library not only serves as a resource for local residents but also as a symbol of the community’s resilience and commitment to preserving its history.
The closure of the Women’s House of Detention in 1971 marked a significant turning point for Greenwich Village. It brought an end to a notorious chapter in the neighborhood’s history and paved the way for the preservation of the Jefferson Market building. The transformation of the old courthouse into the Jefferson Market Library is a powerful example of how communities can reclaim and repurpose their spaces. This story of change, activism, and preservation continues to inspire and reminds us of the importance of community engagement in shaping the spaces we live in.
If you are interested in learning more about historical preservation and supporting the work that Village Preservation does consider becoming a member and check out our advocacy work.