Five years ago this Sunday GVSHP and other community and preservation groups held a Rally to Save the South Village. More than 150 people including elected officials, community and business leaders and neighbors turned out on April 11, 2011 to call upon the City to landmark the remainder of the South Village and save this historic neighborhood from further destruction and out-of-scale new development.
This was an important stop along the way in our ongoing effort to preserve and protect the South Village. We’ve made tremendous progress, but the job is still not entirely done.
To recap: nearly ten years ago at the end of 2006, GVSHP submitted a proposal to the City for landmark designation of the South Village, the area south of Washington Square Park and West 4th Street which was at the time largely lacking in landmark protections. The proposal was the result of four years of exhaustive research on this 40-block area by GVSHP and a report we commissioned by renowned architectural historian Andrew Dolkart on the history and architecture of the South Village, supporting our argument for landmark protections for the area. The report and proposal documents the South Village’s unique historic significance as an archetypal immigrant community and as a crucial stepping-stone for Italians in America; as a laboratory of working-class architecture and an intact vestige of turn-of-the-last century New York; as the site of important cultural innovations and events; and as an important location in the history of New York’s African-American and lesbian and gay communities. The proposed designation was even more compelling because so much of the 19th and early-20th century built fabric of the area remained intact. This is one of the few places where the landscape of working-class New York was virtually unaltered.
In 2010, the NYC Landmarks Preservation Commission designated the first third of our proposed South Village Historic District known as the Greenwich Village Historic District Extension II. Though the victory was sweet, there was still much to do. 83 Thompson/182 Spring Street was slated for demolition and new development. The Children’s Aid Society had also begun to solicit bids for its multi-building site on Sullivan Street touting the unused development rights which would allow a much larger, taller structure on the site. Additional sites were coming under threat and/or demolished in the area that still had yet to be designated.
On April 10, 2011, GVSHP held a rally in front of the Children’s Aid Society on Sullivan Street calling upon the City to landmark the remaining two-thirds of the proposed South Village Historic District as soon as possible. Scores of neighbors, parents, and preservationists joined GVSHP and and speakers included City Councilmember Margaret Chin; Simeon Bankoff, Executive Director of the Historic Districts Council; Sean Sweeney, former Director of the SoHo Alliance and former Chair of the Landmarks Committee of Community Board 2; Jonathan Geballe, former President of Village Independent Democrats; Heather Campbell of Save A Village Education; and Professor Jerome Krase of Brooklyn College, a past president of the American Italian Historical Association. View the video HERE and HERE.
We continued the pressure by seeking New York State “Seven to Save” designation for the South Village. On March 21, 2012, Jay DiLorenzo, President of the Preservation League of the State of New York announced the inclusion of the South Village on the League’s annual “Seven to Save” list, which highlights endangered historic places throughout the state. To further increase the pressure, we also pursued listing for the entire South Village on the New York State and National Registers of Historic Places, which was finalized in December of 2013 (click HERE for the designation report).
We then made a great leap forward when in December 2013 the LPC finally designated the South Village Historic District (map), a two hundred forty-building, thirteen-block section of Greenwich Village south of Washington Square Park, and the second phase of the Greenwich Village Society for Historic Preservation’s (GVSHP) proposed South Village Historic District. GVSHP had fought hard to get several NYU buildings originally excluded from the district included, and had more or less forced the City to move forward with this landmark action by leveraging the approval process for the nearby Hudson Square Rezoning. The South Village Historic District was the largest expansion of historic district protections in Greenwich Village since 1969.
But our job was far from complete. The LPC refused to designate the final third of the district, and had excluded an important row of buildings on the north side of Houston Street between MacDougal and Sullivan Streets from the district.
GVSHP has continued to push the City to designate the final third of the South Village in order to provide the same landmarks protections the area to the north now enjoys. Additionally, GVSHP has proposed the rezoning of the South Village to the City as was done in the East Village in order to protect the neighborhood from out of scale development.